Skip to main content

The 2022 NFL Draft is nearly here, and many NFL fans are anxiously yet excitedly anticipating who will be joining their teams. While the Colts fans don’t have to worry about Day 1, barring a trade-up in this regard, most are laser-focused on Day 2 for Rounds 2-3. However, a vast majority of the players to be added to the Colts will be Day 3 picks, and Ballard isn’t afraid to surprise fans with players they might not have heard of. Here are six sleeper prospects that Colts fans might not have heard of but fit Ballard’s criteria and could be excellent additions to the roster on Day 3.

James Mitchell, TE, Virginia Tech


In a deep and athletic TE class, it is easy to overlook James Mitchell. “The Governor” has not done pre-draft athletic testing or competed in the Shrine Bowl or Senior Bowl, thanks to a knee injury suffered in his final season. That injury cost him all but two games of his final year, And now it’s costing him the pre-draft hype he deserves.



James Mitchell was a highly versatile threat for the Hokies, lining Up as an H-back, in-line TE, & slot receiver effectively. With 16.9 yards per catch, Mitchell is both a deep threat vertically and a YAC mismatch. He even has been used as a goal-line Rushing threat on sweeps and FB runs, with five rushing TDs on seven college carries, a tactic that Frank Reich has employed successfully, too, with Eric Ebron in 2018.


His hands are solid, and if he can get healthy and continue to grow as a high-effort blocker, he could be a valuable late-round TE who far outperforms his draft slot. Health is the major factor, but Ballard isn’t afraid to take those risks. Pre-injury was a round 3-4 graded player, but he could fall to the 200s picks. James Mitchell screams Ballard value pick and would be an excellent addition to the TE rotation.

Tycen Anderson, SS/LB/nCB, Toledo


Another versatile chess piece, this time in the back 7 of the defense: Tycen Anderson, is a load of fun to watch. A long and rangy defender who excels at matching up vs. TEs or slot WRs or RBs out of the backfield, Tycen helps eliminate passing threats in the middle of zones and crash down on the flats. In the run game, he can struggle at the point of attack at shedding blocks but has excellent range and can use his length to wrap up well and even poke the ball out from unsuspecting ball carriers.



Anderson needs to be a bit better at backside defending the run and improve his decision-making if asked to go to single-high looks at Safety. But if he cleans up a few of his fixable flaws and either embraces his versatility or commits to a role, he can carve out a spot on an NFL defense. His special team abilities certainly will help him make a roster too.



As a team captain who was the heart of the Toledo Defense, Tycen’s leadership was never in question, and he has excelled in both the Senior Bowl and the Combine to get a few more people to turn some heads. Consistently flashing his elite athleticism, he is a strong candidate for Gus Bradley and Ron Milus to develop. I could see some sub-package usage as a rookie, or an even bigger role should injuries hit the secondary. Bare minimum, he is a player that Bubba Ventrone will love to use on special teams.

Jerrion Ealy, RB, Mississippi


A versatile pass-catching RB with good speed, smart and efficient cuts, excellent lateral agility, and reliable hands who has return ability… sounds pretty familiar to Colts fans. If that brief scouting breakdown reminds you of Nyhiem Hines, you are correct, and it also applies to Jerrion Ealy.



Ealy might not be as fast as Hines; he shows a lot of Hines traits and provides depth at each of the roles that Hines produces in. While Hines has been durable so far in his career, the RB positions’ injury rates are always high, and in the event of injury, there isn’t a player in the roster who can fully play all the roles that Hines does. Not a pressing need for the Colts, but sometimes it’s good to be forward-thinking, especially late on day 3.


Alontae Taylor, CB, Tennessee

Alontae Taylor is a draft crush of mine. The Volunteer corner is an ideal scheme fit at corner for the Colts and some (consider him a potential Safety as well). Long, athletic, with press man/match to Cover 3 skills, Alontae is exactly what the Colts value in their CBs.



However The Athletic’s Dane Brugler has sees Taylor’s future in a different spot:

Taylor was primarily an outside corner for the Volunteers, but he has versatility across the secondary, and a move to safety might be his best option because of his range and physical demeanor. He will see a heavy dose of special teams in the NFL and might be a team’s best option at gunner. (Dan Brugler’s Big Board, The Athletic


In either spot, though, Alontae brings the requisite physicality, speed, length, and versatility to Indy that would be an instant fit. At the bare minimum, he’d provide phenomenal ST ability and depth. With patience behind experienced players, he could develop into a great player in the latter half of his rookie contract with the Colts. However, should injuries hit the safety or corner position, he could be thrust into a larger role much earlier and have the opportunity to really impress.

Tanner Conner, WR/TE Idaho State


Tanner Conner is this year’s Jacob Harris: an athletic, big WR prospect who is a bit raw but might be best-suited sliding in as a TE in the pros. If that description makes you think that he’s a bit slow as a Wide Receiver, his 4.37 40-yard dash speed at 6’3 225lbs should silence those doubters, as should his 39.5” vertical and 10’7” broad jump should his explosiveness be in doubt either.



Athleticism is one thing, and should he make the position change and bulk up, those metrics will likely decrease to certain degrees, but has his athletic talents translated to production on the field? 127 catches for 2,282 receiving yards (17.97 yards per reception) and 15 TDs for his collegiate career certainly is notable production. He showcased his ability as a burner deep threat vertically and was able to use that superior speed and agility to put up solid YAC production. Combine that with strong blocking, and it’s safe to say that he dominated FCS competition when called upon.


Skillset-wise, while Tanner showed he could win with raw athleticism, he still needs refinement. His hands are okay, but he does not take advantage of his long frame pop-up as he tends to have concentration drops and occasionally body catches. While he is agile, he needs to hone his route running and releases further to trick defenders. He was able to beat defenders in press well during the Shrine Bowl, his ability to produce against more polished Corners is still relatively unknown. Tanner is definitely a project WR/TE in either role, but the athletic ceiling is tempting to take a shot on Day 3. Ballard has done so before in prior drafts at WR, so don’t be surprised if Tanner or a similarly built and athletic WR is drafted late by the Colts yet again.

Blaise Andries, OL, Minnesota


After the offseason departures of Eric Fisher, Sam Tevi, Julien Davenport, Mark Glowinski, & Chris Reed along the Offensive Line, it’s safe to say the Colts need to address depth along the line in this draft class at every position. So why not get an athletic freak OL who has experience at every single spot on the line? Enter Blaise Andries.



The aforementioned versatility was not hyperbole; Andries has starting experience on the Golden Gophers OL at every single spot, especially at both sides of the line at Tackle and Guard. He might be too big to be a center at 6’6.5 & 315lbs (hence why that was the spot he had the least experience in), but the versatile OL has the most experience at RG. He started all 47 games over his four years in Minnesota, showing remarkable durability as well.



While he tested very well in Indy for the Combine, his tape is a bit underwhelming. Andries’s height created pad-level issues that hurt his leverage, and he needed to improve his bend, lateral movement, and punch location to maximize his athleticism. He is a brilliant player, his technique needs refinement, but he gets to his spots well and has the athletic potential to be a great OL if he settles in one spot and hones its technical aspects. He was a PFF grade darling and went up against some tough competition, and over the last two years, allowed only 11 hurries, 6 QB Hits, & 1 sack in 509 pass pro snaps.


The upside is there for Blaise Andres. The immense versatility allows him to be vital depth at nearly anywhere, giving him the opportunity for immediate impact no matter who drafts him should injuries hit the depth ahead of him.


Thanks for visiting The Blue Stable. You can join the conversation on Twitter at @TheBlue_Stable

Jay Robins

Twitter: @RobinsLucas Instagram: Lucas._.Robins

Leave a Reply