All Roads Lead to Berlin: The Colts’ Redemption Tour Begins
The Indianapolis Colts are no strangers to adversity, but last week in Pittsburgh, they got their wake-up call.
Six turnovers. Twenty-four points allowed off mistakes. A seven-point loss that left a disciplined team searching for answers. It wasn’t just a defeat; it was the punch in the mouth every contender takes at some point in a season.
Now comes the response.
Olympic Stadium Berlin © Camera4
This week in Berlin, the Colts trade the cold steel of Acrisure Stadium for the bright lights of Olympiastadion, arriving with purpose. This isn’t a getaway. It’s a turning point. A redemption stop on foreign soil, with the bye week looming and the Chiefs waiting at Arrowhead on the other side.
But this team didn’t flinch. They reloaded.
In one of the boldest moves of the Ballard era, Indianapolis landed All-Pro corner Sauce Gardner, the league’s top-graded coverage defender since 2022, sending two future first-round picks to the Jets. To some, it looked reckless. To Chris Ballard, it looked like the final piece of a championship puzzle.
Before finalizing the deal, Ballard reportedly asked team owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon if offering multiple first-rounders was too steep. Her response captured the mindset of this entire Colts season: “Do you want to Band-Aid it or fix it for the long term?”
That was all Ballard needed to hear. The deal got done.
Gardner now fills the one hole that had shadowed this defense all year: a true lockdown corner capable of erasing any WR1 in football.
As I wrote earlier this week, “Even in his so-called down year, Sauce ranked top 20 percent in passer rating allowed and 16th in yards per cover snap. Pairing him with Lou Anarumo’s disguise-heavy system is a nightmare for quarterbacks.”
The trade sent a message. The Colts believe their window is open right now. And while no one expects Daniel Jones to reset the quarterback market, he’s earned the chance to be the long-term answer. A top-12 contract feels likely, especially if this redemption run becomes a playoff push.
Team Context
The Colts’ trip to Berlin comes at a crossroads. One team is doubling down on its identity; the other is trying to remember it.
For Indianapolis, this is what “All Chips In” football looks like. The front office pushed its draft capital to the middle of the table with the Gardner trade, and the locker room responded in kind. There’s a confidence humming through Shane Steichen’s team that wasn’t there a month ago. Even after the Pittsburgh collapse, the Colts didn’t spiral. They took the punch, learned from it, and started talking about redemption before they left the locker room.
Steichen’s message has stayed consistent: control what you can, correct what you must, and attack everything else. The offense that led the league in balanced efficiency before last week still believes it’s the most dangerous unit in football when it plays clean. With Gardner cleared from concussion protocol, Lou Anarumo’s defense suddenly looks like the version the staff envisioned back in training camp.
For Atlanta, Berlin represents something else entirely: survival. After a 2–2 start, the Falcons have dropped three straight and will travel without starting guard Matthew Bergeron and possibly Chris Lindstrom. Raheem Morris’s defense still fights, but the offensive rhythm has vanished. Second-year quarterback Michael Penix Jr. has talent and toughness, but inconsistent protection has capped his growth.
The contrast couldn’t be clearer. The Colts are fine-tuning for a postseason run. The Falcons are trying to stop the bleeding. One side is betting on belief; the other is just trying to stay afloat.
Coaching Chess Match
If “All Chips In” starts in the front office, it’s Steichen and Anarumo who have turned it into identity.
Steichen’s offense is built on tempo, decisiveness, and adaptability. Before Pittsburgh, Indy ranked top five in time of possession and red-zone efficiency. Even after six turnovers, Steichen didn’t waver. His message stayed the same: stay aggressive. That’s how this team wins.
Anarumo’s defense is quietly one of the league’s most complex. His rotating coverages, delayed blitzes, and hybrid fronts confuse quarterbacks pre- and post-snap. And now, with Gardner active, the playbook fully opens. Gardner’s ability to lock down one half of the field lets Anarumo send disguised pressure without exposing his secondary.
The biggest beneficiary could be second-year pass rusher Laiatu Latu, fresh off a 2.5-sack breakout in Pittsburgh. With quarterbacks forced to hold the ball longer, Latu’s burst and timing could turn hurries into sacks.
For Atlanta, the challenge is survival. Zac Robinson is still searching for balance in his second season as offensive coordinator. Meanwhile, defensive coordinator Jeff Ulbrich has gotten effort from veterans like Jessie Bates and A.J. Terrell, but the defense has been stuck defending short fields.
The Colts are dictating terms. The Falcons are reacting.
Key Matchups
1. Colts’ Front Seven vs. Falcons’ Offensive Line
With Bergeron out and Lindstrom banged up, Atlanta’s protection is vulnerable. The Colts’ front of Grover Stewart, Kwity Paye, and Latu has been relentless, and with Gardner locking down receivers, sacks could come in bunches. Expect Anarumo to dial up blitzes from Zaire Franklin and Germaine Pratt to exploit communication gaps inside.
2. Sauce Gardner vs. Drake London
Gardner’s Colts debut comes against Atlanta’s physical wideout Drake London. London’s strength makes him a go-to target when the pocket collapses, but Gardner’s technique and length can erase that safety valve. Since 2022, Gardner has allowed just 41 percent completions in man coverage. If he forces Penix to check down, the Colts’ linebackers will feast.
3. Jonathan Taylor vs. Kaden Elliss and Jessie Bates
Atlanta’s defensive leaders, Elliss (54 tackles, 6 TFL) and Bates (47 tackles), will be tested by Jonathan Taylor, who has rediscovered his burst. Taylor’s vision and acceleration have reignited Indy’s red-zone attack. If he gets rolling, the Falcons’ defense won’t be able to catch its breath.
4. Pittman & Downs vs. A.J. Terrell Jr. and Mike Hughes
Before the Pittsburgh loss, Pittman and Downs combined for 172 yards and a touchdown. Terrell remains solid, but Hughes has been targeted heavily in off-man coverage. Look for Steichen to use crossers and tempo early to establish rhythm and set up vertical shots later.
5. Steichen’s Pace vs. Robinson’s Patience
Few matchups highlight contrast like this one. Steichen thrives on controlled aggression and quick tempo. Robinson, meanwhile, is playing conservatively to protect his young quarterback. If the Colts dictate the pace early, this game could snowball quickly.
X-Factors & Prediction
Daniel Jones: Composure Over Chaos
Pittsburgh rattled him, no question. After the strip sack, you could see shades of his Giants days. But Jones doesn’t need to play hero ball this week. He just needs to be steady. When he trusts his pocket and stays on rhythm, this offense runs like clockwork. Berlin is his chance to prove he’s grown past those old habits.
The Offensive Line: Five Seconds of Faith
The Colts’ front five cracked last week, and that can’t happen again. Against Brandon Dorlus, Zach Harrison, and Elliss, protection, recovery, and communication will be everything. Give Jones time, and Steichen’s full playbook opens up. Lose focus, and the rhythm breaks before it starts.
Sauce Gardner: The Missing Piece
His presence changes everything. With Gardner anchoring coverage, Anarumo can send creative pressures and let Latu and Paye hunt freely. The Colts’ front doesn’t need more time now, except that they do…
Even with Gardner transforming the coverage unit, the loss of DeForest Buckner looms large. His absence tests the heart of this defensive front and challenges Grover Stewart and Adetomiwa Adebawore to hold the line. What once was a strength built on dominance now has to be rebuilt on depth and discipline. For a team built on next-man-up mentality, this is the kind of moment that defines belief.
Focus and Finish
Every overseas trip tests focus, but Steichen has kept this team grounded. The mantra hasn’t changed: finish drives, finish tackles, finish games. Berlin isn’t about spectacle, it’s about identity.
Prediction
Both teams enter with something to prove. The Falcons are desperate to stay afloat; the Colts are determined to remind the league that one loss doesn’t define them.
Indianapolis plays its most complete game of the season, leaning on Taylor’s balance, Jones’ poise, and Gardner’s debut impact.
Colts 32, Falcons 13.
A business trip disguised as a statement, and the first stop on a redemption tour that’s just getting started.
More from The Blue Stable:
